Gain Dish Detergent Review: Original Scent

by Taylor

I've been seeing Gain dish detergent on the shelves for months now at the store, and finally broke down and bought some to try when I saw a cute little mini bottle for sale cheap.

I'd been wanting to know what it smelled liked, and how it worked for a while and thought this was a great time to do so.

I chose the Original scent (that comes in green), but there are also other scents available. These include Spring Lavender (purple), Apple Berry twist (red, and formerly known as Apple Mango Tango - but may have been reformulated), Honeyberry Hula, with bleach alternative (bluish turquoise), and antibacterial Lemon Zest (yellow).

I admit I debated for a while about which one to buy, and may still go back to try the Apple Berry scent sometime (I'm a sucker for apple scents), but I figured the first time I would try the classic one.

I don't actually use scented laundry detergents, but am strictly a hypoallergenic laundry detergent kind of girl, so I'll be the first to admit I don't really know what the original scent of Gain should smell like. (Of course, they've recently changed the scent, and there is a large contingent of people who hate the new scent of Original Gain). Therefore, I'm not sure the scent matches the detergent or not, but it did smell pleasant and vaguely fruity, although I couldn't put my finger on exactly what it was supposed to smell like.

I will tell you though, if you're looking for a strong scent, this is not the soap for you. Although it smells nice in the bottle not much scent lingers while you're actually standing at the sink washing your dishes.

I didn't buy Gain dish soap just to sniff it though, so what I was most interested in was how it worked to clean dishes.

like a thick dishwashing soap, and Gain dish detergent did not disappoint me. It was not runny at all, but my husband complained that the dispenser hole at the top of the bottle was a bit big, which meant too much came out too quickly. Since I bought the mini bottle I don't know if that is just a problem with this little bottle or would also be a problem with the larger version as well.

It worked well for cleaning my dishes, and cut grease on pots and pans as you would expect dish soap to do.

It met my standards, but didn't exceed them. Frankly, it worked about the same as Ajax dish soap, which is significantly less expensive.

For people that like fun scents though, and are looking for a competitor for Dawn dish soap which more and more people are complaining to me causes their dish rags and sponges to stink this may be it.

Gain Dish Detergent {Referral Links}

I used to see Gain dish detergent at the dollar stores, where you could buy a big bottle for a dollar, but I'm now starting to see it less at such stores and more in regular stores, and the prices are creeping up as you would expect a name brand to do. Soon I'm afraid it will get as expensive as Dawn (both of which are made by Procter & Gamble).

This brand of dish soap appears to be getting pretty popular, even though it is relatively new to the market. Therefore, I'd love to hear from even more people who've tried it, in any of the scents, sharing how it has worked for you and your thoughts on it.

You can share your share your dishwashing soap review here for this or any other brand, or you can also click the link to read reviews from others for many brands, which have already been submitted.

Click here to post comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to dishwashing soap.

Gain Ultra Antibacterial Lemon Zest Dishwashing Liquid/Hand Soap Review

by Heidi
(Homewood, IL)

Heidi says:

I usually don't buy antibacterial dish soaps, but the Gain dishwashing liquid was on sale for a really good price at the time so I bought it and the antibacterial was the only one left on the shelf.

Would I buy it again for everyday washing? Not really. The smell is too strong and it seemed like I had to use more to get greasy jobs done. I don't like having to add more. It just bugs me.

However, there was a very specialized task this dish soap did tackle, which amazed me.

We are soon to move into my late mother's house, which needed a lot of work and cleaning.

She had a vermin infestation. Now with any infestation, you will find droppings everywhere.

Needless to say, I found a box of expensive glassware in the basement that was tainted with said droppings. (Ewwwwww!)

I hated the idea of tossing the glasses out though. They're really nice. I decided to wash them and see what would happen.

First, I tried using a heavy duty, multi purpose, powder detergent the pros use.

It took several washings but those glasses eventually came out clean and fresh, but it was hard on my hands. Really hard on my hands. (I can't where latex gloves. I have a lovely allergy to latex, so I'm bare handed with deep water scrubbing.)

The initial wash water also stank of detergent and droppings. Not a pleasant odor. I'm repulsed at the mere memory of it. Bluck!!!

I don't know why, but I decided to try the Gain Antibacterial dishwashing liquid.

It ended up being a breeze. The glasses left to soak in hot water with the Gain, and then washed in same water, came out clean in one wash.

Although I did wash them a second time for my own mental comfort. LOL!

On top of that, the initial wash water didn't have the stinky smell left behind from the droppings that I got from the powder detergent. The wash water smelled like the Gain.

So not only did this dishwashing liquid remove the nasty stuff, but it killed the odor too.

It's worth it to me to keep some on hand for my experience with it alone even though I won't be using it everyday.

Taylor says:

Thanks so much for sharing your review Heidi.

I'd love to hear from even more people who've used this product, in any of the scents, to tell me how it worked for you. You can share your review here.

Click here to post comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to dishwashing soap.

Did Not Care For This Dish Soap & Won't Try It Again

by Christine

I have purchased the original version of this soap before.

I did not care for it and would not and have not used it again.

It smelled good but was too thin, so you had to use more and it did not last.

It also did not clean dishes easily or very well.

In my opinion it is far less superior to Dawn dish soap, which I think is the very best one out there.

I do like the Gain detergent though, but do not buy that either because the price has been jacked up significantly over the last couple of years.

Click here to post comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to dishwashing soap.

Both Dawn & Gain Dish Soap Cause Smelly Sponges

by Chrissy
(Las Vegas, NV)

Chrissy says:

After using Palmolive dish soap for years, I wanted to try something with a different scent. (I had been buying the huge jug of Palmolive dish soap available at Costco, which only came in one scent, original green).

I had coupons and tried Dawn, which caused my sponges and hands to have the moldy smell previously mentioned by others.

I threw away the Dawn, and used some leftover Palmolive in a small bottle that we kept in our motor home. It was the antibacterial orange version, and we had no issues with it.

I saw some small bottles of Gain dish soap for less than a dollar, so I tried the original scent until I could get back to Costco.

I was unpleasantly surprised that with Gain soap, my sponge immediately started stinking again.

I checked out Gain here on this site, and learned that it is made by the same good folks who make Dawn. Perhaps they are sharing ingredients, as the result was certainly the same.

Back to Palmolive for me.

Taylor says:

Thanks for sharing your review of the Gain dish detergent Chrissy, but sorry it caused your sponges to smell.

I personally did not notice that problem when I used it, but it certainly has been a problem for many people who use Dawn, and it makes sense that Gain could also be effected, since the same company, Procter & Gamble, manufactures both products.

I'd love to hear from even more people who've used this soap, in any of the scents, telling me what they liked, or didn't, about it and why.

You can share your reviews here of this or any other brand, or read other reviews which have already been submitted.

Gain Dish Detergent {Referral Links}

Related Pages You May Enjoy

{A-H} House Cleaning Supplies Reviews

Gain Laundry Detergent Reviews & Information

Go From Gain Dish Detergent Reviews To Home Page

There are affiliate links on this page, and if you purchase a product through them I receive a small commission. Purchasing through my links costs you nothing extra, but helps support the free information provided on this site and my family. To learn more please see my product review disclosure statement.

Comments for Both Dawn & Gain Dish Soap Cause Smelly Sponges

Click here to add your own comments

comparison between Dawn and Gain
by: Marilyn

I have used Dawn and Gain dishwashing detergents, and I see no difference in them! They look so similar, that I looked to see who makes them, and discovered that Proctor & Gamble makes both of them! I figure that they come from the same formula with different fragrances added. As of right now Gain is slightly cheaper in price than Dawn. Both work well, cut grease, and leave dishes clean.

Never had a problem
by: Anonymous

I love Gain Antibacterial soap. Works better than Dawn and cost less. It definitely works better than Ajax dish soap. It lathers well and the dishes are squeaky after being washed. I cannot find Gain Antibacterial dish soap anywhere anymore. Maybe because Proctor & Gamble knows Gain works better than Dawn too. Stinky sponges comes from washing dishes with food still in them. I do not like food in my dish water, so I always rinse my dishes before I was them, and I put a little bleach in the dish water. I never have stinky sponges no matter what dish detergent I use.

Gain is not the same as Dawn
by: Larry

I've tried different scents of Gain. Although it's made by Proctor and Gamble like Dawn, the thickness is about the same, and the bottle looks similar, it's not as good as Dawn and not as sudsy. You need more to do the same job. Tricky marketing.

Gain also makes sponges smell
by: Anonymous

Yeah. I refuse to use it. Mrs. Myers doesn’t do that. Neither does Ajax (for those big families who can’t afford Mrs Myers or Seventh Generation).

Love it, for dishes and as shampoo
by: Anonymous

You won't believe it unless you try it, but this dishwashing liquid is a great shampoo! Leaves hair strong, shiny, and scalp healthy! (Great for dishes too.😀)

made my sponge smell bad
by: Anonymous

Just wanted to let people know that Gain ultra, the green color dish soap, also made my sponge smell bad. I heard Palmolive doesn't cause the smelly sponge, is it any Palmolive dish soap or only a certain one?

very disappointed
by: Anonymous

I am very disappointed with Gain’s dish detergent. I love the clothes detergent, but my dishes feel greasy and still dirty. The suds disappear and there is a greasy residue left in the water for the rest of the dirty dishes. The dishes feel greasy after being washed! I hope they will make improvements and I will try it again.

Allergic reaction
by: Barbara

I had a very bad reaction to Gain Laundry soap so I avoid it. I've had no other problem with any other laundry soap and am able to buy whatever is on sale with no problem as long as it is not Gain! But recently I tried the Gain dish soap thinking because it's not in my clothes it would be fine. After two days I had rash on both hands that started going up my arms. I quit using the dish soap realizing even the dish soap will cause hives for me. It took a few days for the rash to go completely away but I will never buy another Gain product of any kind.

also causes bad smell
by: Stephen Macpherson

Bought Gain dish liquid because of bad smell with Dawn. I'm having same issue. I went to Gain's website and they are made by Proctor & Gamble. That parent company also is the maker of Dawn. Bought Palmolive and no more issues.

P&G dish soaps cause a smell
by: Lucy MacNaughton

I have experienced smelly sponges using Dawn as long ago as the year 2000. It did not matter what fragrance I bought, the sponge stunk within a week of using a new one. Recently my husband bought a bottle of Gain, also a Proctor and Gamble dish detergent and the same thing happened. At first I was blaming the sponge brand but I now know that is not it. The only solution I have found was to stop using P&G liquid dish soaps. I tried using a dish cloth at first thinking it was the sponges but it didn't make a difference. You pick it up and the stench stays on your hands. I have trouble believing that over all these years they have not been contacted by customers regarding this. So after all these years if they have not figured it out and fixed it, I guess they just do not care. Looking for a new product.

make my sponges smelly almost immediately
by: Heather

Both Dawn and Gain dish soap make my sponges smelly almost immediately, all scents. Have had no problems with Ajax, Method and other more organic detergents. Dawn and Gain are supposed to be phosphate free so perhaps whatever they subbed in for the phosphate is causing the problem and reacting with the cellulose.

seem to make my sponge stink tremendously after a few uses
by: The dishwasher of the house

Both dishwashing detergent brands, Dawn and Gain, no matter what fragrance I use seem to make my sponge stink tremendously after a few uses. And believe me that's half the number of times I wash dishes in one day. And it's only with these brands. Not to mention even if I wash my dishes off completely, the fragrance seems to stay on the dish. When I put food on these "clean" plates I not only smell the soap, but my fingers have the nasty sponge smell. You know, it's expensive enough as it is to me to get good sponges and dishwashing detergent, though I never welch on good sponges, cheap dishwashing liquid NEVER leaves my dishes smelling like soap, nor do they give me a nasty sponge smell. Fix it.

Disappointment - aroma boost is too strong
by: Anonymous

I love the original scent of Gain dish detergent WITHOUT the aroma boost! Original was just a clean smell to me. The aroma boost is too strong. I was thrilled when I found the original scent online without the aroma boost. However, when I received it, it had the aroma boost! Now I am returning it.

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to dishwashing soap.

Thanks For Visiting My Website: Grab Your Free Gift!


Hi, I'm Taylor, a busy mom with 3 kids, so I have lots of hands on experience with house cleaning, laundry and my fair share of spots, spills and other messy catastrophes. Thanks for visiting my site.

I update the website all the time with tips, tutorials, cleaning recipes, reviews of products from readers like you, and tests I've done on various cleaners, removers and laundry supplies.

I'd love to give you a gift! When you subscribe to my free weekly newsletter you will receive a free printable laundry stain removal chart that you can reference as needed.

I hope you enjoy this gift, and stop by again soon!

Subscribe To The Out Darn Spot Newsletter

* indicates required

CAUTION: This website is provided for informational purposes only. It is provided as is, without warranties or guarantees. Some stains and messes just won't come out, and are permanent. Further, some cleaning methods can harm your item, so if what you want to clean or launder is sentimental or expensive call a professional. See disclaimer of liability for more information.