Low Sudsing Detergent - Myth Busted - It Can Work Just As Well

If you've been a follower of this site for a while you know one of the big parts of the site are all the cleaning and laundry product reviews I've got that are written by readers, just like you.

Overall I am so very proud of these reviews, and spend a lot of time adding them to the site, because I think they are a huge unbiased help to everyone to find products that work, versus which ones don't.

But every once in a while I run into a complaint about a product that I find unfounded, so I try in comments or in other commentary to explain why what that particular person has complained about should be taken with a grain of salt.

And here's one that I have gotten over and over about _______ (fill in the blank) brand of laundry detergent. The complaint is -- this product is horrible because it doesn't suds.

There are many reasons why a detergent might be a huge disappointment, and I agree some of them are pretty horrible and I would not use them. But let's complain about something that truly makes a difference instead of the amount of suds.

So I'm going to let you in on a secret. The amount of suds that are made by a laundry detergent have absolutely NOTHING to do with the cleaning power of that product.

The Marketing Myth Of Suds

From a scientific perspective it is important to state, from the get go, that there is a difference between a "soap" and a "detergent."

For soaps, the amount of suds DOES make a difference in its cleaning power.

However, this is NOT the case for detergents.

That being said, a long time ago when laundry detergents (versus laundry soaps) first came out marketers wanted to prove their products worked well. So they perpetuated the myth that suds were necessary for detergents, and showed they were working, just like is the case for soaps.

That marketing ploy eventually turned into a commonly held belief amongst people that no suds = horrible detergent.

The Rise Of HE Machines

Unfortunately for laundry detergent manufacturers their marketing ploy has now come back to bite them in the backside amongst many consumers.

The reason is that the newer washing machines, especially the high efficiency and front loading varieties need to use HE detergent. As I've explained in more detail in my ultimate guide to HE laundry detergent the reason is that HE detergents are, by definition, low-sudsing detergents. They have to be because suds mess up and even damage the components of HE machines
which use significantly less water then the older washer models.

So now because of changes in technology manufacturers cannot just add ingredients which increase the amount of suds in a detergent, but instead have to remove those ingredients from their products so they can work in HE machines properly,

Further, even if you don't personally own a high-efficiency machine chances are the detergent you're purchasing these days is called "dual use," meaning they can be used either in a traditional or HE machine.

The reason manufacturers are making dual use detergent is that it is easier to create one product that works for both types of machines then having to have separate lines depending on the machine you use.

That means that everyone is seeing less suds in their laundry detergent when they pour a bit into the machine then they were years ago.

Consumers Are Noticing The Lack Of Suds & Complaining

I can tell just from all the complaints I've personally received from readers that they are noticing this lack of suds and many have formed bad impressions of the detergent they tried for this very reason.

Or, they've wasted quite a bit of the detergent pouring more and more in trying to make suds because that is what they expect to happen, and believe the clothes cannot get clean without them.

But for the reasons I've already explained this criticism is completely unfair!

So here's my public service announcement to everyone. Do not conclude, based on lack of suds, that a detergent is sub-par.

Instead, give it a go despite not seeing bubbles when you add it to your machine. Try it, with the amount recommended for use, and not extra which is a waste of money and can cause detergent residue to stay in your clothes (which itself can make your clothes feel dirty and yucky) and make a decision about whether you like it based on other criteria.

If it doesn't remove stains, makes you itch, leaves a yucky smell behind, doesn't actually clean soil, etc. then that still is not a good detergent. But lack of bubbles shouldn't be something you consider, either way.

Oh, and if you want to check out all the laundry detergent reviews on the site you can do so here. At last count I've got over 130 pages of reviews of just about every brand and type imaginable!Photo by Clearly Ambiguous

Related Pages You May Enjoy

Laundry Tips & Tricks For Busy Moms

Best Laundry Detergent For You: Reviews & Ratings Of Major Brands

Go From Low Sudsing Detergent Is Becoming More The Norm To Home Page

Comments for Low Sudsing Detergent - Myth Busted - It Can Work Just As Well

Click here to add your own comments

Suds does not equal clean
by: Anonymous

Most people are under the impression that suds or bubbles means cleaning power. That is not true. In fact, if you are seeing suds your clothes are probably holding on to soap residue. Manufacturers recommend the correct amount of their product based on testing, not suds. Save yourself money and use only what is recommended.

That's what my washer manufacturer told me too!
by: Anonymous

I was told by the company who made my washer, which is a front loader, that manufacturers have changed many of the laundry soaps so that you will not get anywhere near as many suds as they used to. This is especially true for the front loaders, which typically use HE detergent.

I don't think it rinses well
by: Anonymous

I find low suds detergent does not rinse as well. To see for yourself do a load as usual. Then start another cycle with the same load, but add a nylon mesh 'grocery bag' to the load. A light foam results and rinses well.

question: did vinegar ruin my soap nuts liquid?
by: fractal cat

I have been using soap nuts for nearly three years now, and love them. I both add them in little bags to the wash and also use frozen liquid cubes. About every six months I make a large batch of liquid and freeze it into ice cubes and add a couple of cubes to each load. I simmer the soap nuts for about 4 days in a big crock pot before freezing it into cubes.

I usually add some vinegar, but this time I started with distilled water but afterward added only white vinegar across the four days, about a gallon of white vinegar total. My liquid hardly has any suds, even though it is always really strong. This batch should be out-of-sight strong. Do you think all that vinegar ruined my liquid? I am making another huge batch right now in the crock pot, but this time with NO VINEGAR to compare the batches. Your post says there is no correlation between suds and effectiveness. Does that hold for soap nits as well? Because a lot of very light, frothy suds usually come from my batches. :-0

Can't get the suds out
by: Tiny

I have an High End Whirlpool washer so use He Tide in both the delicate and Orange regular. My problem is although I use very small amounts, like a quarter size I have to reset and reset the machine to get all of the soap out. How do I know that the soap is not all out? I have a laundry tub the water drains in to. I use less because I have a water softener. Any help for me.

HE detergent is the REAL gimmick.
by: Anonymous

Biggest marketing gimmick is HE laundry detergents, period. Have used ‘regular’ laundry soap in three different front loaders for the last 15 years with fine results. JUST USE LESS SOAP.

HE soap is ridiculously over-priced.

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to household tips for laundry.

Thanks For Visiting My Website: Grab Your Free Gift!


Hi, I'm Taylor, a busy mom with 3 kids, so I have lots of hands on experience with house cleaning, laundry and my fair share of spots, spills and other messy catastrophes. Thanks for visiting my site.

I update the website all the time with tips, tutorials, cleaning recipes, reviews of products from readers like you, and tests I've done on various cleaners, removers and laundry supplies.

I'd love to give you a gift! When you subscribe to my free weekly newsletter you will receive a free printable laundry stain removal chart that you can reference as needed.

I hope you enjoy this gift, and stop by again soon!

Subscribe To The Out Darn Spot Newsletter

* indicates required

CAUTION: This website is provided for informational purposes only. It is provided as is, without warranties or guarantees. Some stains and messes just won't come out, and are permanent. Further, some cleaning methods can harm your item, so if what you want to clean or launder is sentimental or expensive call a professional. See disclaimer of liability for more information.